You’ll find something that will satisfy your sweet tooth!

Book An Appointment Request A Quote Order Online

Bakery Menu

  • Bakery Menu

Custom Party Cakes

Our party cakes come with two cake layers and a filling in-between. Prices below include an inscription and standard buttercream decoration (e.g. flowers, balloons, dots). Standard cakes are available for online ordering. If you are interested in a custom decorated cake, prices vary greatly. It's always best to call us and schedule an appointment for any wedding, tiered, or shaped cake, as custom quotes require a fair amount of staff time. Samples are by appointment only. 708-614-9755.

  • 6" Round Custom Party Cake (serves 6-8)
    $25.95
  • 8" Round Custom Party Cake (serves 12)
    $35.95
  • 10" Round Custom Party Cake (serves 20)
    $48.95
  • 1/4 Sheet Custom Party Cake (serves 26)
    $61.95
  • 12" Round Custom Party Cake (serves 36)
    $73.95
  • 1/2 Sheet Custom Party Cake (serves 50)
    $89.95
  • Large 1/2 Custom Party Cake (serves 72)
    $111.95
  • Full Sheet Custom Party Cake (serves 100)
    $156.95

Specialty Cakes

Here are some great combinations to choose from! Please visit our online store to order online.

  • Becky's Cheesecake
    Light and airy with a graham cracker crust

    6" (Serves 8) - $21.95
    9" (Serves 14) - $36.95
  • Atomic Cake
    A local favorite! From top to bottom: White cake, fresh strawberry filling, banana cake, fresh bananas in custard, fudge, and chocolate cake. Iced with whipped cream. Available in our case on weekends only.

    8" (Serves 12) - $53.95
    10" (Serves 20) - $70.95
    1/4 sheet (Serves 26) - $90.95
    12 " (Serves 36) - $98.95
    1/2 sheet (Serves 50) - $118.95
    Large 1/2 sheet (Serves 72) - $142.95
  • Flourless Chocolate Cake
    Attention chocolate lovers! This is a dense, rich chocolate cake iced in ganache. Our raspberry sauce accompanies it in a separate container. This is a great choice for those that are on a gluten-free diet by choice. We do not recommend any of our products for those with Celiac disease.

    6" (Serves 8) - $21.95
    9" (Serves 14) - $36.95
  • Tiramisu Cake
    Our version layers our light chiffon cake, soaked in a Kahlua-espresso syrup, with sweetened Italian mascarpone cheese. Iced with whipped cream and dusted with cocoa.

    6" (Serves 8) - $37.95
    8" (Serves 12) - $53.95
    10" (Serves 20) - $70.95
    1/4 sheet (Serves 26) - $90.95
    12" (Serves 36) - $98.95
    1/2 sheet (Serves 50) - $118.95
    Large 1/2 sheet (Serves 72) - $142.95
  • Citrus Torte
    A light, delectable treat! This 4-layer torte consists of thin layers of chiffon cake with lemon. lime, and orange mousse in-between, with buttercream icing.

    6" (Serves 8) - $36.95
    8" (Serves 12) - $43.95
    10" (Serves 20) - $60.95
    1/4 sheet (Serves 26) - $75.95
    12" (Serves 36) - $81.95
    1/2 sheet (Serves 50) - $98.95
    Large 1/2 sheet (Serves 72) - $115.95
  • Luscious Lemon
    4 layers of chiffon cake, with 2 layers of lemon mousse and 1 layer of royal lemon fillings. Iced with yellow lemon buttercream icing.

    6" (Serves 8) - $37.95
    8" (Serves 12) - $53.95
    10" (Serves 20) - $70.95
    1/4 sheet (Serves 26) - $90.95
    12" (Serves 36) - $98.95
    1/2 sheet (Serves 50) - $118.95
    Large 1/2 sheet (Serves 72) - $142.95

Grab n' Go Cakes

Need a last-minute cake? We've got you covered. The following cakes are available in our display case every day (unless indicated). Grab n' Go Cakes are first come, first served.

  • Bananutella Cake
    Banana cake with hazelnut mousse filling, chocolate buttercream icing, and a dark chocolate ganache drizzle

    6" (serves 8) - $29.95
    8" (serves 12) - $41.95
  • Chocoholic Cake
    Something for chocolate lovers! Chocolate cake, chocolate mousse filling, and chocolate buttercream icing. Decadence!

    6" (serves 8) - $29.95
    8" (serves 12) - $41.95
  • White Cake with Raspberry Mousse
    White cake with raspberry mousse filling and buttercream icing. Decoration may vary.

    6" serves 8) - $25.95
    8" (serves 12) - $35.95
  • Banana Split Cake
    Layer of banana cake and a layer of chocolate cake with strawberry preserves and strawberry mousse filling. Iced in whipped cream with a ganache pour-over. Decorated with whipped cream dollops and cherries on top.

    6" (serves 8) - $29.95
    8" (serves 12) - $41.95
  • Neapolitan Cake
    A layer of white cake and a layer of chocolate cake with strawberry mousse filling and buttercream icing. Decorated like Neapolitan ice cream.

    6" (serves 8) - $25.95
    8" (serves 12) - $35.95
  • Yellow Cake with Chocolate Mousse and Fudge Filling
    Yellow cake layers with chocolate mousse and fudge filling. Bright and festive decoration.

    6" (serves 8) - $25.95
    8" (serves 12) - $35.95
  • Yellow Cake with Fresh Strawberry Filling
    Yellow cake layers with fresh strawberries in glaze for filling. Whipped cream icing. May be decorated to specification (flowers, bright and festive) upon pickup.
    Weekends only.

    8" (serves 12) - $43.95
  • Oreo Cake
    Chocolate cake layers with Oreo mousse filling and Sweet Stuff Buttercream icing. Decorated with a ganache pour-over, whipped cream dollops, and chocolate sprinkles.

    6" (serves 8) - $30.95

Custom Cupcakes

Cupcakes come in the same flavors as our cakes, with the exception of our chiffon cake. For filled cupcakes, we use our mousse fillings. Cupcakes are usually topped in buttercream. Sprinkles are included in standard decoration, but other decoration charges may apply, depending on design. Please visit our online store to order online.

  • Custom Cupcakes - Filled
    $2.95
    each, or $32.45 per dozen
    Custom Cupcake orders require a minimum of 3-7 days notice. Minimum order is 1 dozen per kind. Discount of $2.95 is applied to each dozen purchased.
  • Custom Cupcakes - Unfilled
    $2.45
    each, or $26.95 per dozen
  • Mini Custom Cupcakes - Filled
    $1.25
    each, or $27.50 for 2 dozen
    Mini cupcakes are perfect when you are serving lots of small desserts. Each cupcake is 2-3 bites. Flavors are the same as with our standard cupcakes. A discount of $2.10 applies to every 24 cupcakes.
  • Mini Custom Cupcakes - Unfilled
    $1.05
    each, or $25.10 for 2 dozen

Grab n' Go Cupcakes

The following is selection of our readily available gourmet cupcakes. Scroll down to see our seasonal flavors!

  • Bananutella Cupcake
    $2.95
    Banana cupcake with hazelnut mousse filling, ganache icing, and a toasted hazelnut for decoration.
  • Chocolate Bliss Cupcake
    $2.45
    An unfilled chocolate cupcake with buttercream icing and chocolate curls for decoration.
  • Classic Carrot Cupcake
    $2.65
    It's a classic! Carrot cake with cream cheese icing and a little carrot on the top. (Unfilled)
  • Confetti Cupcake
    $2.45
    White cake filled with sprinkles and topped with buttercream star tip icing & multi colored nonpareils. (Unfilled)
  • Hostess with the Mostest
    $2.95
    We took this childhood favorite to the next level! This is our delicious chocolate cupcake with vanilla mousse filling and ganache icing. Decorated with a white chocolate swirl.
  • Strawberries and Cream
    $2.95
    This is a white cupcake with strawberry mousse filling and strawberry buttercream icing. Topped with white chocolate shavings.
  • Peanut Butter Cup Cupcake
    $2.95
    Chocolate cake with peanut butter mousse filling and chocolate buttercream icing. Topped with a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup candy and ganache and peanut butter drizzle.
  • Southern Red Velvet Cupcake
    $2.65
    Our moist red velvet cake with cream cheese icing and red velvet crumbs for decoration.
  • Sundae Cupcake
    $2.95
    Chocolate cake with whipped cream filling, buttercream icing, and a chocolate drizzle. (Unfilled)
  • Very Vanilla Cupcake
    $2.45
    White cake with buttercream icing and white chocolate curls. (Unfilled)

Mini Pastries & Individual Desserts

We have a variety of miniature pastries available daily! Many of these items may be picked up in the store or pre-ordered. Please visit our online store to order online. Scroll down to see our seasonal treats!

  • Mini Eclairs
    $1.45
    , or $15.95 per dozen
    Puff pastry eclairs filled with scratch custard and topped with chocolate icing and a white chocolate drizzle.
  • Miniature Brownies
    $1.45
    each, or $15.95 per dozen
    Our cake-like chocolate brownies are one of our most popular items. Dusted with powdered sugar on top.
  • Mini Cream Puffs
    $1.45
    each, or $15.95 per dozen
    Traditional pate choux mini cream puffs filled with custard and vanilla mousse filling.
  • Lemon Squares
    $1.45
    each, or $15.95 per dozen
    Luscious, creamy lemon filling over a buttery shortbread cookie crust. Topped with a sprinkling of powdered sugar.
  • Raspberry Bars
    $1.45
    each, or $15.95 per dozen
    These cobbled fruit bars contain raspberry preserves and crunchy pecans.
  • German Apple Bars
    $1.45
    each, or $15.95 per dozen
    Chunks of granny smith apples, cinnamon, and walnuts baked into a soft bar. Topped with cream cheese icing.
  • Mini Cherry Cheesecakes
    $1.45
    each, or $15.95 per dozen
    A plain mini cheesecake topped with a dollop of cherries and whipped cream. We also have Mini Cheesecakes with lemon topping.
  • Mini Tiramisu Slices
    $1.85
    each, or $20.35 per dozen
    A square of our chiffon cake soaked in a Kahlua-espresso syrup, filled with sweetened mascarpone cheese and iced in whipped cream. Topped with a chocolate covered espresso bean and a dusting of cocoa.
  • Tiramisu Slice - Large
    $3.95
    each
    A square of our chiffon cake soaked in a Kahlua-espresso syrup, filled with sweetened mascarpone cheese and iced in whipped cream. Topped with a chocolate covered espresso bean and a dusting of cocoa.
  • Mini Cream Puff Swans
    $1.85
    each, or $20.35 per dozen
    Traditional pate choux mini cream puffs filled with custard and vanilla or chocolate mousse filling. This fancier version of a cream puff is made to look like a swan.
  • Coconut Macaroons
    $1.85
    each, or $20.35 per dozen
    A moist pyramid shaped coconut macaroon. The bottom is dipped in chocolate.
  • Mini Cannoli
    $1.85
    each, or $20.35 per dozen
    A crisp cannoli shell filled with cannoli cream and mini chocolate chips. Decorated with chocolate chips on the ends. Our cannolis can be special ordered with chopped pistachios on the ends.
  • Cannoli - Standard Size
    $3.95
    each
    A crisp cannoli shell filled with cannoli cream and mini chocolate chips. Decorated with chocolate chips on the ends. Our cannolis can be special ordered with chopped pistachios on the ends.
  • Mini Turtle Cheesecakes
    $1.85
    each, or $20.35 per dozen
    Mini chocolate swirl cheesecakes with pecans baked inside. Topped with caramel and ganache drizzle and pecan accents.
  • Mini Strawberry Cheesecakes
    $1.85
    each, or $20.35 per dozen
    Strawberry-swirled cheesecakes with fresh strawberries and whipped cream topping.
  • Brownie Pops
    $2.65
    each
    Our Brownie Pops can be dipped in chocolate or white chocolate with a contrasting drizzle. Colors can be customized for custom orders (12 per kind, 1 week's notice required).
  • Chocolate Dipped Strawberries
    $22.95
    per pound
    Dipped in chocolate or white chocolate and drizzled with an accent color. Approximately 10 per pound.
  • Chocolate Dipped Pretzels
    $1.15
    each, or $12.65 per dozen
    Crunchy pretzel rods dipped in chocolate or white chocolate and drizzled with the color of your choice.
  • Rice Krispie Treats
    $2.95
    each, or $32.45 per dozen
    Rice Krispie Treats on a stick and dipped in the color of your choice. Accented in drizzle or sprinkles.

Miniature Pastry Trays

A variety of miniature pastries pre-arranged for your get-together. These can be ordered online, in-store, or call us at 708-614-9755

  • Traditional Mini Pastry Tray - 12"
    $32.95
    12" round tray with 20 pieces of mixed traditional pastries. Traditional pastries include raspberry bars, brownies, lemon squares, cherry and lemon cheesecakes, cream puffs, eclairs, and truffles.
  • Traditional Mini Pastry Tray - 16"
    $58.95
    16" round tray with 40 pieces of mixed traditional pastries.
  • Gourmet Mini Pastry Tray - 12"
    $40.95
    12" round tray with 20 pieces of mixed gourmet pastries. Our gourmet assortment of pastries includes: cannoli, cream puff swans, coconut macaroons, chocolate dipped strawberries, tiramisu slices, turtle and strawberry cheesecakes.
  • Gourmet Mini Pastry Tray - 16"
    $73.95
    16" round tray with 40 pieces of mixed gourmet pastries.

Cookies by the Pound

Choose from several varieties of cookies. Pricing is determined by the pound. Approximate counts per pound are listed in each description. (images are enlarged to show texture)

  • Spritz Cookies
    $16.95
    per pound
    Spritz cookies in a variety of shapes with seasonal decorations. Flavored with a hint of almond. Boxed by the pound. Approximately 50 ct per pound.
  • Spumoni Cookies
    $16.95
    per pound
    Cherry, vanilla, and chocolate striped cookies with almonds. Approximately 25 ct per lb.
  • Pinwheel Cookies
    $16.95
    per pound
    Vanilla and chocolate swirled together with seasonal sugar decoration on the outside. Boxed by the pound. Approximately 17 ct per pound.
  • Mini Butter Cookies
    $16.95
    per pound
    A mix of mini chocolate and vanilla butter cookies with sprinkles. Approximately 60 ct per pound.
  • Italian Wedding Cookies
    $16.95
    per pound
    This powdered sugared cookie ball is a family favorite. Contains almonds. Boxed by the pound. Approximately 25 ct per pound.
  • M&M Cookies
    $16.95
    per pound
    Crisp cookies with M&M candies. Approximately 20 ct per pound.
  • Peanut Butter Cookies
    $16.95
    per pound
    Classic peanut butter cookies. Approximately 20 ct per pound.
  • Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
    $16.95
    per pound
    Oatmeal cookies with raisins, walnuts, and cinnamon. Approximately 26 ct per pound.
  • Kolacky
    $16.95
    per pound
    We carry an assortment of raspberry, cheese, and apricot kolacky. Approximately 22 ct per pound.
  • Chocolate Chunk Cookies
    $16.95
    per pound
    Just like chocolate chip cookies, but with larger pieces of chocolate. Approximately 26 ct. per pound.
  • Brookie
    $16.95
    per pound
    Looks like a cookie, tastes like a brownie. Approximately 16 ct. per pound.

Macarons

A French almond meringue sandwich cookie with a creamy filling. Available to order online.

  • Assorted Macarons
    $2.25
    each
    A French almond meringue sandwich cookie with flavored fillings. Macaron flavors change with the season. Call us to get the latest flavors! Please visit our online store to order online.

Cookie Trays

An assortment of cookies on a pre-arranged tray. Perfect for large parties! Please visit our online store to order online.

  • Cookie Tray - 12"
    $38.95
    Assorted cookies on a pre-arranged tray. Each tray weighs 2 lbs and contains 30 to 40 cookies.
  • Cookie Tray - 16"
    $72.95
    Assorted cookies on a pre-arranged tray. Each tray weighs 4 lbs and contains 60 to 80 cookies.

Seasonal Items

Paczki are now available! Valentine's treats will be available starting on Friday, January 18th.

  • Emoji Cupcakes
    $3.15
    These cuties are made with yellow cake and topped with buttercream icing.
  • Heart-Shaped Cookie
    $15.95
    This jumbo chocolate chunk cookie is made in the shape of a heart. Personalize it with a sweet message!
  • Heart-Shaped Cheesecake
    $10.95
    Becky’s delicious cheesecake, topped with fresh strawberries in glaze with whipped cream. Perfect for two
  • Heart-Shaped Cheesecake with Chocolate Ganache Icing
    $15.95
    Becky’s cheesecake, covered in rich dark chocolate ganache and topped with two chocolate-dipped strawberries. A sweet indulgence just right for two people!
  • Valentine's Day Brownie Pops
    $2.85
    each
    Our delicious fudgy brownies, rolled into a ball and dipped in chocolate or white chocolate.
    Decorated with cute Valentine’s sprinkles!
  • Chocolate Dipped Strawberries
    $23.95
    per lb.
    You can’t go wrong with these gems! They are dipped in chocolate and white chocolate, then accented with a red and pink drizzle. The average yield for 1 lb of chocolate dipped strawberries is 8 - 12 strawberries.
  • Cherry Shortbread Cookies
    $17.95
    per lb.
    Buttery chocolate-dipped cookies with maraschino cherries. Perfect with a hot cup of coffee or tea!
  • Valentine Heart Cookie
    $3.15
    This classic sugar cookie comes in a variety of colors with cute phrases piped on! (phrases will vary)
  • Macaron Flavors
    $2.25
    Red Velvet
    Dark Chocolate Mint
    Cappuccino
    Winter White Chocolate
    Birthday Cake
  • Atomic Mash-Up Paczki
    $2.99
    Our Atomic Cake in Paczki form: half fresh strawberries, half fresh bananas in custard, and chocolate icing with a ring of whipped cream.
  • Boston Paczki
    $2.99
    Filled with custard and topped with rich chocolate icing.
  • Bananas Foster Paczki
    $2.99
    Filled with fresh bananas folded into rum custard and topped with caramel icing. *Contains alcohol
  • Turtle Paczki
    $2.99
    Filled with caramel mousse and topped with chocolate icing, plus a drizzle of caramel and pecans. *Contains nuts
  • Maple Bacon May-ham Paczki
    $2.99
    Filled with maple custard, iced with maple glaze, and topped with bacon.
  • Fresh Strawberry Paczki
    $2.99
    Filled with fresh strawberries in a strawberry glaze with a ring of whipped cream.
  • Cannoli Paczki
    $2.99
    This paczki contains our cannoli filling and topped with powdered sugar. *Available for pre-orders only
  • Rumchata Paczki
    $2.99
    Filled with rum custard and topped with sweet icing and cinnamon. *Contains alcohol // *Available for pre-orders only
  • Apricot Paczki
    $1.99
    Stuffed with apricot filling and topped with powdered sugar. *Available for pre-orders only
  • Coconut Cream Paczki
    $2.99
    Filled with coconut cream and topped with white icing and toasted coconut. *Available for pre-orders only
  • Cherry Paczki
    $1.99
    Jam-packed with cherry filling and topped with powdered sugar. *Available for pre-orders only
  • Lemon Paczki
    $1.99
    Royal lemon filling and topped with powdered sugar. *Available for pre-orders only
  • Raspberry Paczki
    $1.99
    Filled with raspberry preservatives and topped with powdered sugar. *Available for pre-orders only
  • Lemon Paczki
    $1.99
    Royal lemon filling and topped with powdered sugar. *Available for pre-orders only
  • King Cake
    $24.95
    Serves 15 // Chiffon cake with a cinnamon orange pecan streusel throughout. Topped with orange flavored icing. In King Cake tradition, a plastic baby is hidden inside! *Contains nuts

Locations

Tinley Park

16649 Oak Park Ave
Tinley Park, IL 60477

708-614-9755

Naperville

55 S. Main St Ste 355
Naperville, IL 60540

630-365-7580

Hours

Tinley Park

Tuesday – Saturday: 8am to 6pm
Sunday: 8am to 4pm
Closed on Monday

To book an appointment please call 708-614-9755 or book online.

Naperville

Bakery orders for pickups Wednesday through Saturdays. Consultations by Appointment. To book an appointment please call 630-365-7580 or book online.

Explore

Creative Cakes Rewards

Sign up for the Creative Cakes Rewards Program & receive delish perks throughout the year!

Get Creative Cakes Rewards

© Copyright 2019 Creative Cakes Bakery. | Store Policies